This is, I think, my favourite story of the season so far. It tackles similar issues to Rosa. In this case swap the struggle for Civil Rights in the American South for the terrible events following the Partition of India in 1947. It isn’t a pure historical. There are aliens. But it is a close as we are going to get to one in post-2005 Doctor Who. It is written by Vijay Patel.
Yaz gets a gift from her Nani (Leena Dhingra). It is a watch with a shattered face. She won’t tell the story of it but Yaz asks the Doctor to help her answer some questions. The Doctor has doubts. Dropping into family history never ends well but eventually agrees. Using the watch as a guide for the TARDIS to find a location they find themselves dropped into the mountains of Punjab, not Lahore. Which was expected.
They start walking, but the Doctor gets a psychic whack from something. As they’re trying to work out what is happening a carriage pulls up. Inside is Prem (Shane Zaza). Yaz asks if he knows where Umbreen is and he says he’ll take them. He offers a lift to an older Hindu Sadhu but the Sadhu says he will walk.
They arrive at a shack where they find Umbreen. It turns out that Umbreen, a Muslim is about to marry Prem, a Hindu. And the chose to do it on the day the British partition India and create the new state of Pakistan. The division between Hindu and Muslim.
Partition, as the Doctor realises, is a catastrophe. There was violence and there was mass migration as the religious minorities in both countries made their way to what they perceived were safer locations. It’s estimated that around 14 million people were displaced. The Punjab was the sight of horrific violence. Hundreds of thousands of people were killed. Maybe as many as a million.
The thing that Demons of the Punjab does is humanise that story. Only two people die in this story. One of them we don’t really know but the other we do. It is up there for me with the death of Bellboy in The Greatest Show in the Galaxy in terms of bleakness. Perhaps worse because Partition was real.
In the story the Doctor, Yaz, Graham, Ryan, and Prem find the Sadhu’s corpse. And standing by him two alien figures. Prem drives them off. It turns out he has seen them before. On a battlefield. Standing over his dead brother. Prem served with the British Army in World War Two.
The Doctor recognises them as Thijarians, a race of Assassins. So, there’s a lot of running around trying to locate their HQ, find out what they’re up to and stop it. Whilst at the same time pushing on with Prem and Umbreen’s wedding.
The Doctor though eventually discovers that the Thijarians are no longer assassins. They are the last of their species. Whilst they were away on a mission their world was destroyed and they chose to bear witness, across all space and time, to those who were dying alone and add a sample of their DNA to a hive. They are here because Prem is about to die.
Prem’s younger brother, Manish (Hamzah Jeetooa) killed the Sadhu. He has become a Hindu nationalist. He has organised a group to come and end the wedding and marriage.
When they realise they are coming Umbreen and her mother flee. Prem goes out to confront his brother and his armed friends. Unarmed. The Doctor, Yaz, Ryan, and Graham have been watching but the Thijarians appear and tell them that they will witness Prem’s final moments. I like the idea of there being a species out there in the universe that act as witnesses to those who are going to die alone. How they decide who to witness on a planet where millions of people die every day in a universe filled with planets of dying peoples is an interesting question, but I suspect will be unanswered. I don't know if we'll ever see Thijarians again. I like though to think of the Thijarians as a metaphor for historians, but that's just my bag.
They turn to leave and go back to the TARDIS. We hear a shot.
The last scene is Yaz talking to her Nani again.
It is so well acted by everyone. Especially Mandip Gill. Bradley Walsh gets some fine moments too. And Shane Zaza and Hamzah Jeetooa as Manish are brilliant too. The final confrontation between the brothers is impressive work.
It looks fantastic. It was filmed in Spain, which helps make it look a little like Punjab. This season has filmed in South Africa too.
To finish though this is such a good story, which tells a story that we non-Asian British have probably forgotten. I remember when this came out arguing with someone about this story and they said, ‘it happened so long ago why are we still going on about it.’ I pointed out that my Dad was born in 1947. This is something that happened in living memory, not hundreds of years ago.
The ending always moves me.
My
only tiny quibble is why the older Umbreen doesn’t recognise Yaz, especially
when she sees the henna tattoos on her hands from the wedding. And what if
she’d bought the Doctor, Ryan and Graham round? Or perhaps she did, which is
why she gave her the watch? The paradoxes of time travel.

No comments:
Post a Comment