Begun as a story by story blog of my Journey Through the Whoniverse this is a Doctor Who review blog. If you haven't seen any of the stories then beware the dreaded SPOILERS. If you want detailed reviews this ain't the place. These are more spur of the moment instant judgements focusing on what gets my attention. I hope you like it. PS I am currently crowdfunding a Doctor Who book. You can find more about it here - https://unbound.com/books/time-and-space/
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Death to the Daleks
It's another Terry Nation Dalek story...forgive me if I don't look too excited. Like Planet of the Daleks, this is not the most exciting of stories but does throw in a few Nation cliches.
The most annoying of which is saving the Daleks until the end of the first episode so that they can play their cliffhanger role. This would be fine if the story did not give the game away IN ITS TITLE. Sorry. I'm not sure what came over me there, Nation fatigue?
Anyway as Doctor Who stories go it is distinctly average. The TARDIS lands and is mysteriously drained of all its power whilst the Doctor and Sarah Jane are on their way to the lovely Florana. (This 'let's go somewhere nice...oops didn't make it' is one of the series reoccurring tropes. It'll keep the writer's happy forever).
Setting out to investigate the Doctor is grabbed by a bunch of grunting primitives - later revealed to be called Exxilons - from whom he escapes and then stumbles across a party of Marine Space Corps who have landed on Exxilon in search of Parrinium (Macguffin of the Week), which is needed to save the Outer Worlds from a mysterious space plague. They've been stuck here since their ship was forced to land after a similar power drain. They are made the wounded and soon to die Commander Stewart (Neil Seiler) Richard Railton (a totally wasted John Abineri), the plucky Jill Tarrant (Joy Harrison), the wet Hamilton (Peter Fox) and the grumpy Scotsman Galloway (Duncan Lamont).
Meanwhile Sarah has gone off exploring and stumbled across a rather impressive City. The Daleks arrive, threaten to exterminate everyone but find their weapons do not work because of the energy drain. They must work with the humans but everyone is captured and Railton dies (thus wasting Abineri totally, which should be an executable offence really).
Sarah is to be sacrificed by the grunting Exxilons for trespassing in their City, which is sacred to them. The Doctor tries to rescue Sarah but succeeds only in adding himself to the sacrificial party.
The Daleks, having fitted themselves with old school machine guns, set about massacring Exxilons, bullying humans and mining the Parrinium. Commander Stuart snuffs it, after telling Galloway that he is totally unfit for command. (For some reason I kept thinking about George Galloway at this point...not sure why)
The Doctor and Sarah escape and start exploring the roots of the city when they bump into Belal (Arnold Yarrow) who a non-grunting Exxilon. The Daleks start Parrinium mining, chase the Doctor and decided to blow up the City's beacon after they've had a look round.
The Doctor and Belal enter the City just ahead of the Daleks, whilst Sarah and Jill set about getting the Parrinium onboard the Earth ship ready for when the energy drain ends. The City, which is sentient and a bit up itself, had been responsible for primativising (a word I happily makeup, you may take it with you and use it to your heart's content) the Exxilons who were previously an advanced, space-traveling type civilization. It's also a complicated series of traps and tricks: secret entrances, mazes, electrical floors, etc.
The Doctor gives the City a nervous breakdown, a couple of panicked Daleks are chased out of the City by the antibodies it created...then the Daleks ignore a perfectly good opportunity to eliminate the Doctor - again - and flee the planet with what they think is the Parrinium but isn't and much to their surprise Galloway and a bomb. Boom! Galloway redeems his grumpy, realpolitik Scottishness. Jill and Hamilton get to take the Parrinium away. Hurrah!
Which makes it all sound quite exciting but in fact it is all a little dull. Quarries, grunting primitives and a slow trip through a city do not fun and frolics make.
Galloway seems to be a character from another much bleaker Terry Nation story who stumbled into Death to the Daleks. He's surely an escapee from Blake's Seven or a Survivor. Lamont actually plays him quite well. He at least seems three dimensional unlike the rest of the Space Marine lot who are either bumped off at speed or wet but plucky.
Pertwee's a bit flat in this I think as if he's not really that impressed but Liz Sladen's doing a great job as Sarah Jane. She does a great job of conveying quite a lot in a brief glance or lip purse.
Also, Arnold Yarrow's Belal is a lovely little performance for a man stuck inside glowing plastic. He's quite sweetly brave when he joins the Doctor on exploring the City.
It's better than Planet of the Daleks but that's damning with very faint praise indeed and is only four parts long so doesn't drag as much.
I'm a bit surprised actually. This is one of the stories that I'd watched (and liked) before but revisiting is a disappointment, like Tomb of the Cybermen was.
O well. Next stop Peladon.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment