Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Witchfinders


I really enjoy the Witchfinders. Partly because it is an era of history that I’m fascinated by, partly because I went to University in Lancaster and Lancaster Prison is where the Pendle Witches were hung. Or some of them. They do an interesting tour if you ever get a chance to go. 

This was also my favourite story when I first watched this season. Especially because I liked Alan Cummings’s performance as James I. Cumming can be a tad…arch on occasion. But here he feels right for the part. James I did consider himself an expert on Witchcraft. He wrote Demonologie in 1597. I think Cumming does an excellent job of conveying the ‘wisest fool in Christendom.’ 

The Doctor and friends arrive in a village near Pendle Hill in Lancashire. They find a old school dunking going on. Led by Becka Savage (Siobhan Finneran), a local landlord and magistrate. The Doctor tries to save the woman but fails. 

She fakes being The Witchfinder General, but the arrival of King James himself puts an end to that. This is the first story that addresses The Doctor now being a woman. So far it has gone unmentioned. It doesn’t last long though. I said a while back that if the Doctor cast a woman in the role there was going to be an issue about how much they addressed that and how much they carried on as normal. I think it has gone mostly unremarked until this story. But I think there’s an element of cowardice in that. 

Rosa addressed the issues of Ryan and Yaz’s race (even if Yaz was mistaken for Mexican) and the problems that might cause but The Witchfinders is the only story that – so far – takes on the issue of the Doctor's feminine presentation. And even then, it is quickly brushed over. A female Doctor tackling the Witch trials should have had more depth to it in my opinion, but it is all played relatively lightly. But then this is the Doctor Who and Nazi problem. How 'real' can Doctor Who ever get with real history? With all its violence and horror? 

Anyway Willa Twiston (Tilly Steele) is the granddaughter of the murdered ‘witch’ and takes her body to bury it. The Doctor sends Yaz after her. Everyone else goes off with King James, who has decided that Graham is the Witchfinder General and The Doctor is his assistant. He also takes a shine to Ryan, which is historically plausible. 

The moment when Ryan and King James talk about James’s life is quite a thing. His life is a long list of trauma and danger. 

While Willa is burying her Nan a tentacle rises from the mud and tries to attack her. Previously executed witches started rising from their graves and it all gets a bit creepy. Then Becka Savage accuses The Doctor of being a witch, which Willa, terrified supports. 

She is tied to a tree awaiting a ducking. 

There’s a great two hander here between the Doctor and King James that is well-played by both Jodie Whittaker and Alan Cumming. It’s a gentle interrogation, but you’re not quite sure who is questioning who. It’s my favourite bit of the episode. 

The Doctor is ducked. But escapes. Another reference to Houdini. She confronts Becka Savage and it is revealed that she, when chopping down a tree, was infected by an alien presence. She saw it as demonic and has been trying to find a cure. But the tree was an ancient prison holding the Morax, another unpleasant murderous species that we’ve never encountered before. Becka gets taken over by the Queen Morax and she and her ‘Zombie’ horde snatch King James intending to make him the King Morax. 

The Doctor uses chunks of the tree to drive the Morax back into the tree, which releases the Witch Zombies who drop dead. The Doctor watches as King James burns the Queen Morax as if she were a real witch. An act that, quelle surprise, the Doctor disapproves of even though we saw no other solution at that point. Honestly, this has always been a thing the Doctor does. There should always be another way, but I it irritating by Jodie Whittaker’s Doctor never seems to come up with plausible solutions. I know...I suspect James I's reaction is part of the point. A pin in the foolish thinking of Stuart England, but people in the past didn't know all the things we know. Even now when we know many, many things people chose not to believe them. The people in the past are like us, but they are also unlike us. Cruelty is always cruelty, but sometimes people didn't know better. Or most people didn't. There are always people who are against cruelty or ignorance but we don't often hear from them.  

The story ends with the crew leaving in the TARDIS in front of a confused King James and an amused Willa. 

The performances are great; the story is fun – if a bit basic Doctor Who. Tosin Cole is great. I enjoyed Tilly Steele’s Willa. In 60s Doctor Who - and with a smaller crew - they might have taken her with them as a companion. Troughton definitely would have. Mandip Gill still feels a bit under used. But very entertaining. More of this kind of thing please.

No comments:

Post a Comment