Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Destiny of the Daleks



We kick off Season 17 with 'Destiny of the Daleks', written by Dalek creator Terry Nation. I have grown tired of Terry Nation's scripts over the course of this blog because it seems to me that having created The Daleks back in 1963 Nation got lazy. The best Dalek stories tend to be written by other writers.

However the additional input of script editor Douglas Adams helps breathe some life into this script. It isn't great but it isn't terrible either.

Perhaps the most controversial issue is the light-hearted approach to both Romana's regeneration & the Dalek's themselves. Yes, I think it is a shame that Romana didn't get a 'proper' regeneration story - something I suspect New Who wouldn't have missed out on - and it is a shame that it is such a throw away. In that sense it does make regeneration less 'significant' but the trying on of bodies bothers me less. I've justified it in my head as being some kind of projections for the Doctor to look at whilst Romana tries to get him to approve 'copying' Princess Astra's body.

[18/12/2013 Re-watch note - I notice Romana says she is 'regenerating' through this bit, not 'I've regenerated' implying it is an ongoing process not throwing away incarnations. I also note she refers to herself as a Gallifreyan not a Time Lord. I suppose that can mean something or nothing depending on your point of view.]


The piss taking of the Dalek's is less easy to justify. It undermines them as an enemy, not helped by the rather shoddy looking nature of the Dalek props at this point. In fact this is the point at which, picking up the banner from Genesis, the Dalek's become the muscle to Davros's main villain. They're dull & stupid robots in this story, as opposed to the devious creatures of previous stories. Everyone in the Doctor Who production office at this point seems to have forgotten they are semi-organic. It's Davros that the Doctor gets to pit his wits against.

[18/12/2013 I got more annoyed about this on re-watch. After all Terry Nation wrote both Dalek origins stories so he should KNOW they're not robots. They have, to quote Professor Jansen. 'an organic content'.]

David Gooderson plays Davros this time around, not Michael Wisher. This is a shame because there is something missing from Gooderson's portrayal. I can't put my finger on exactly what it is but it just isn't as sparky. It certainly doesn't feel as 'deep' as Wisher's.

[18/12/2013 And his feet are going like billy-o when he's moving about. Rather obviously]

The other 'enemy' in this story are the robotic Movellan's who I like because they're well designed (sort of disco ancient Egyptians if that makes any sense) & well played by Peter Straker, (the under appriciated but wonderful) Tony Osoba & Suzanne Danielle (although she is a bit more wooden than robotic).

[18/12/2013 There's an interesting story to be written about Movellan origins I think. But I'm a bit weird like that.]

There's also a smattering of prisoners. The main one is Tyssan (Tim Barlow) who doesn't get much to do except deliver the occassional piece of exposition early on & then run around a bit thereafter. Also in amongst the prisoners is a young David Yip (who later went on to play the Chinese Detective in the early-1980s: a series I have fond memories of but haven't seen since it was broadcast).

It's a surprising multi-racial cast for Doctor Who of this period with the Movellan's played mainly by black actors & the human prisoners being a cross-section of all races.

The plot itself is simple. The Dalek's have come to Skaro to find Davros. They need his help to defeat the Movellan's - with whom they've been stuck in a centuries long stalemate. The Doctor & Romana II arrive & hi-jinks follow.

This is the Doctor's first use of the Randomiser, which takes him straight to Skaro, which doesn't bode well does it. If the first thing your randomiser does is take you back to the planet of your greatest enemies I'd be tempted to unplug the thing & do a little rewiring.

Tom's good in this but I should give a nod to Lalla Ward (Romana II). I have a soft spot for Romana II from my childhood. Lalla Ward gives her all the right notes & is basically playing a female Doctor. Her & Tom clearly have chemistry to (although at what point they became an item off-screen I don't know). Anyway it works as a partnership.

So 'Destiny of the Daleks' is OK with the only downside being the Daleks themselves (as I've already mentioned) and the cheap looking nature of the corridors on the Dalek city. One of Season 17's problems - from my memory - is that it is the first time where Doctor Who's financial shortcomings really start to reflect in sets. But I might be being a little harsh as the Dalek control room looks pretty good - even if you can walk into it without any degree of significant hassle, which again undermines the 'threat' of the Daleks.

Perhaps the very definition of average Doctor Who at a time when even the average stuff was pretty good fun.

[18/12/2013 With additional quibbles I'll stick to that judgement.]

No comments:

Post a Comment